The developer of the Isla di Oro project, J.O.B. Holding & Management VBA, has lost their appeal in the Superior Court regarding a legal dispute over construction activities on Isla di Oro, located near Pos Chiquito, Aruba. The case, filed by the Aruba National Park Foundation (now the Aruba Conservation Foundation) and other local environmental organizations, aimed to halt the construction due to violations of nature protection laws.
The Superior Court upheld the ruling of the Court of First Instance, confirming that the construction activities must cease immediately. J.O.B. Holding had appealed the case, arguing that the land was not part of any protected nature areas, but the court disagreed. The ruling means that the company must pay all legal costs and fines, and it also upholds the decision that the leasehold on Isla di Oro cannot be extended unless the project adheres to environmental protection regulations.
Background of the Case
In 2023, J.O.B. Holding acquired the leasehold rights for the Isla di Oro property with plans to build a bar and restaurant. Construction began without the necessary permits, and local environmental organizations filed a lawsuit to halt the work, arguing that it violated nature conservation laws. The Court of First Instance ruled in favor of the foundations in May 2024, and the Superior Court has now confirmed that decision.
Court’s Final Decision
The court ruled that J.O.B. Holding must cover the legal costs and fines associated with the case. It also upheld the decision that the company cannot extend the leasehold unless the project meets the environmental protection requirements. The ruling emphasizes the importance of protecting Aruba’s natural resources and enforcing legal regulations designed to preserve the island’s environment.
Photo Credits: https://diario.aw/categories/noticia/hudicial/desaroyador-di-proyecto-isla-di-oro-a-perde-nan-caso-di-apelacion-den-hof
